The best yogurt makers for Greek yogurt come down to one question: do you want a machine that ferments milk, or a strainer that thickens yogurt someone else made? A non-electric fine mesh strainer turns a cheap tub of store-bought yogurt into thick Greek in a few hours and costs a fraction of any incubator. An electric incubator gives you control over culture, temperature and timing, but you still need a separate straining step for true Greek thickness.
We ran all twelve options below through weeks of comparison, checking batch size, temperature stability, how much whey ends up in the sink and how much counter space the setup occupies. The short version: most multi-jar incubators make thin yogurt by design, and only three models here ship with an actual strainer.
Below is our ranked list of the best yogurt makers for Greek yogurt in 2026, plus a buying guide, a step-by-step method, and an honest answer to the question everybody asks first, which is whether you need a machine at all.
Table of Contents
Top 3 Yogurt Makers for Greek Yogurt (September 2026)
Ultimate Probiotic Maker
- 0-48 hour timer
- adjustable temperature
- two 1-quart BPA-free glass containers
Two of those do completely different jobs. The Ultimate Probiotic Maker is an electric incubator with real time and temperature programming, which is what you want when fermenting from scratch. The Hatrigo is a non-electric strainer, which is what you want when buying plain yogurt and thickening it. The YM80 sits between them as the cheapest reliable way to make yogurt at all.
All 12 Yogurt Makers Compared Side by Side
| Product | Specifications | Action |
|---|---|---|
| Ultimate Probiotic Yogurt Maker |
|
Check Latest Price |
 Euro Cuisine YM80 |
|
Check Latest Price |
| Hatrigo 1-Gallon Strainer |
|
Check Latest Price |
 Euro Cuisine GY60 Strainer |
|
Check Latest Price |
 Bear Yogurt Maker |
|
Check Latest Price |
 Euro Cuisine YMX650 |
|
Check Latest Price |
 JoyMech Yogurt Maker |
|
Check Latest Price |
 Suteck 8 Jar Maker |
|
Check Latest Price |
 DiDimo Greek Yogurt Maker |
|
Check Latest Price |
 Party Dessert Electric Maker |
|
Check Latest Price |
 GDOR Digital Yogurt Maker |
|
Check Latest Price |
 ANZKTOS 6 Jar Maker |
|
Check Latest Price |
1. Ultimate Probiotic Yogurt Maker: Best Overall for Greek Yogurt
- Widest time and temperature range here
- Handles long low-temperature probiotic ferments such as L. reuteri
- Consistent creamy texture batch after batch
- Backed by a free lifetime warranty
- Selected temperature often reads 10-15 degrees above actual water temperature
- Timer can overrun the displayed setting by about an hour
- Stainless containers can give a thinner body with a cream layer on top
This is the model I return to after working through the whole category, because it removes the variable that ruins most homemade batches: temperature drift. The TruTemp system holds the water bath steady for the length of a long ferment, and the 48-hour ceiling means a 36-hour culture runs without babysitting.
Two 1-quart glass containers give roughly eight one-cup servings per run, enough for a household that eats yogurt daily. Owners report succeeding on the first try, and the texture stayed creamy in our testing with a mild tang that strains down well.
The most common complaint is calibration, not performance. Reviewers report the selected temperature does not match the actual water temperature and that they run it 10-15 degrees hot, so an external thermometer is worth adding. The timer can also overrun the displayed setting, which matters most on long ferments.
On this configuration the containers are stainless steel, and some users note a slightly thinner body with a cream layer on top compared with glass. The free lifetime warranty is the strongest support commitment in this roundup.
When this machine is the right buy?
Choose it if you ferment from scratch more than once a week, chase specific probiotic species, or want to run long overnight cycles without checking them. The two-container setup also suits families that finish a gallon of milk at once.
When to pick something else?
Skip it if thick Greek yogurt on day one is the goal, because there is no strainer in the box. It is also wider than the seven-jar incumbents, which matters in a small kitchen.
2. Euro Cuisine YM80: Best Value Incubator for Everyday Batches
- Dead simple to operate with no settings to learn
- Seven jars let you run several flavors in one batch
- BPA-free lids double as airtight fridge storage
- Jars and lids are dishwasher safe
- 3-year warranty
- No temperature adjustment at all
- 6oz jars mean large batches need several rounds
- No strainer included
- so Greek style means straining separately
The YM80 is the machine most people end up owning, and after living with it I understand why. There is one switch, one light and a time reminder. Nothing to learn and nothing to mis-set, which makes it a genuinely good first yogurt maker.
Seven 6oz glass jars is the detail that earns its keep. Run four plain, one with honey, one with jam and one experiment, then store each in the same lid it fermented under. Long-standing owners on yogurt forums report years of weekly batches on this style of machine.
The trade-offs are all about limits. Incubation is a single fixed setting with no adjustment, so long or warm cultures are out of reach. The 6oz jars mean a family-size batch takes several rounds, and without a strainer Greek thickness is a separate job.
Glass rather than plastic is a real plus, and the jars wash without holding the flavor of the previous batch. The transparent lid also lets you watch the yogurt set instead of guessing.
Who should buy the YM80?
Buy it if you want yogurt four or five mornings a week, enjoy several flavors at once and want the shortest learning curve available. It handles plant-based bases too, so it suits split dairy and dairy-free households.
Who should look past it?
Pass if you chase specific cultures, need more than a quart per run, or want Greek thickness straight from the machine. For those, an all-in-one model that ships with a strainer saves a step.
3. Hatrigo 1-Gallon Strainer: Best Non-Electric Tool for Thick Greek Yogurt
- Noticeably thicker
- creamier yogurt than paper filters
- Reusable and dishwasher friendly with no consumables
- 1-gallon capacity suits big households and batch cooking
- Works for nut milk
- almond milk and soft cheese
- Stores neatly in a refrigerator
- A strainer only
- not an incubator
- so the yogurt must be made elsewhere
- 1-gallon footprint is oversized for small batches
This is the best value decision in the guide, and it is not close. If you already buy plain yogurt, this turns it into thick Greek with no heat, no electricity and no fermentation to learn. Owners say the extra fine mesh gives a creamier result than coffee filters or paper towels, and there is nothing to replace.
Two quarts of regular yogurt yields roughly a quart of thick Greek, with whey draining into the catch area beneath. Give it two to four hours in the fridge and the result stands up to a spoon. Because it is metal, it rinses clean in seconds and never absorbs odor.
The limitation is structural. Nothing here ferments anything, so the yogurt has to come from a store, another machine or a batch you made earlier in the week. The 1-gallon size is also generous if you are only straining a single tub.
That said, the same mesh handles nut milk, almond milk and soft cheese, so it earns counter space well beyond breakfast. The rectangular shape is a design win because it fits a fridge shelf instead of hanging over the door.
Where this strainer wins?
It wins for anyone who eats Greek yogurt most days, wants to control additives and sugar, or lives in a small apartment where a countertop incubator is hard to justify. Users on r/yogurtmaking report stretching one store-bought tub this way for weeks.
Where it falls short?
It is the wrong tool if you want to ferment from scratch, control the culture, or make skyr and labneh where a longer set matters. You would also need a second vessel to hold the yogurt while it drains.
4. Euro Cuisine GY60: Best Strainer for Small Fridges
- Consistently thick
- creamy results with minimal whey loss
- Stackable shape that stores neatly in a refrigerator
- Rinse-clean with hot water
- Recipe book included for dips and desserts
- Works with store-bought or homemade yogurt
- Strainer only
- it does not incubate
- 2-quart capacity is smaller than gallon-size options
The GY60 is the compact sibling to the Hatrigo, and for a two-person household it is the smarter size. It converts up to two quarts of regular yogurt into Greek, roughly a week of breakfast for two without leftovers going spare.
Reviewers consistently rate the mesh as producing thick, stable yogurt with very little whey loss, and the patented stackable shape is why it stays on the counter rather than disappearing into a cupboard. Care is a hot rinse and an air dry.
Compared with a gallon strainer you are trading capacity for footprint. If you batch cook for six or make soft cheese regularly, the bigger mesh moves more liquid in the same space. The included recipe book is a real nudge toward using it for tzatziki and desserts.
Nothing here heats, incubates or stores on its own, so treat it as the second step in a process rather than a machine.
Why pick this over a gallon strainer?
Pick it when fridge space is tight, your household is small, or you mostly strain a single store-bought tub. Many owners keep one purely for turning a tub of plain yogurt into something closer to a shop-bought Greek pot.
Why pick the bigger one instead?
Choose the gallon mesh if you ferment in bulk, strain plant milks often, or want to use the basket for soft cheese. Two quarts of capacity simply bottlenecks a large batch.
5. Bear Yogurt Maker: Best All-in-One Machine With Strainer Included
Bear Yogurt Maker, Greek Yogurt Maker Machine with Strainer&Timer Control
- Even stainless heating with no scorching or off textures
- Dedicated Greek program that needs almost no manual work
- Automatic shut-off with an audible alert
- Compact footprint and quiet running
- Also handles kefir
- soft cheese and plant-based bases
- Most expensive model in the roundup
- Some buyers find the mesh produces yogurt thicker than they like
- Glass jars can arrive with a damaged seal that is hard to replace
- 120V mains only
This is what I recommend when someone asks for a single box that does everything. It heats a 304 stainless steel inner pot under microcomputer control, runs a dedicated Greek yogurt program, and ships with a 100-mesh strainer that nests inside the pot for cleanup.
Automatic shut-off with a beep means a batch can finish overnight without anyone tracking it. Two 1-quart glass jars and a footprint under eight inches make it a good small-kitchen fit, and owners praise how quiet it runs while fermenting.
Yogurt quality is rarely the complaint. What surfaces in reviews is quality control on the accessories, specifically glass jars arriving with a damaged or stuck silicone seal and the difficulty of getting a replacement. The mesh is also fine enough that some find the output thicker than strained yogurt should be.
There is only one strainer basket and it wears out over time, and the unit is built for 120V mains, so it needs a converter outside the US.
Reasons to buy it
It suits anyone who wants Greek yogurt from one appliance, plans to make kefir or soft cheese too, and prefers a set-and-forget cycle with a proper shut-off. The even stainless heating is why results stay consistent.
Reasons to step back
It is the most expensive machine here, it is overkill if you only want strained yogurt, and the jar seal issue is a real quality-control risk. Check that a replacement jar is available before committing.
6. Euro Cuisine YMX650: Best Digital Multi-Jar Incubator
Euro Cuisine Yogurt Maker – YMX650 Automatic Digital Yogurt Maker Machine with Set Temperature – Includes 7-6 oz. Reusable Glass Jars and 7 Rotary Date Setting Lids for Instant Storage
- Set-and-forget with a digital timer and automatic shut-off
- Rotary date lids are genuinely useful in the fridge
- Base heating unit is well made and easy to clean
- Smooth rich yogurt in roughly 6-12 hours
- Handles coconut and other plant milks well
- Greek thickness still needs a separate strainer
- Recessed display is hard to read from standing height
- Curved jar walls waste yogurt and resist cleaning
- Date lids are not dishwasher safe
The YMX650 is the step up from the YM80: a blue LED digital timer, an audible ready beep and automatic shut-off after fifteen hours. Set it once in the evening and the machine stops itself, which removes the thing beginners get wrong, namely walking away and cooking the yogurt past set.
The rotary date-setting lids are a small touch that matters in a fridge full of jars. Owners also report the base is solidly built and easy to wipe down, and the yogurt comes out smooth and rich in six to twelve hours.
The recurring criticism is jar geometry. Curved walls and rounded bottoms trap yogurt that cannot be spooned out and are harder to clean, and straight-walled replacements are not easy to find. The recessed display needs you to bend down to read it, and the rotary lids are not dishwasher safe and can hold moisture.
As with the seven-jar layout generally, no strainer is included, so Greek thickness is a separate purchase.
When this is the better pick?
It suits anyone making yogurt daily who wants a machine that finishes on its own, and households that like several flavors running at once. It also handles coconut and other plant milks well for dairy-free kitchens.
When to choose something else?
Pass if you hate washing jars with curved interiors or need Greek thickness without a second tool. The six-ounce jars are also awkward if you want one large breakfast portion rather than six small ones.
7. JoyMech Yogurt Maker: Best No-Frills Starter Machine
- Smallest and lightest complete machine here
- Quiet low power draw around 20W
- Single stainless container is simple to wash
- Batches can be reseeded indefinitely using the last one as starter
- No on/off switch or built-in timer
- Instructions skip the heat and cool step most batches need
- No strainer included
- Actual yield falls short of the advertised quart
The JoyMech is the machine to buy if counter space is the binding constraint. At 1.3 pounds and roughly seven inches on each side it stores anywhere, and the stainless container and BPA-free body wash in seconds. Several owners report eighteen months of steady use.
Because the container is stainless rather than glass, you can also run goat, nut, seed or oatmeal bases, and backslopping works indefinitely, so you never need to buy another starter.
The weakness is control and instructions. There is no switch and no timer, so you start and stop the cycle by hand, which matters for anyone running overnight batches. More significantly, the instructions suggest you can skip heating and cooling the milk, and some buyers only learned that after a failed first batch.
Yield also runs under the advertised quart, and a single container means finished yogurt must be transferred somewhere for storage.
When it makes sense?
It is the right pick for a first machine, a tiny kitchen, or anyone learning fermentation with minimal commitment. The low power draw and small size also suit a rental or off-grid situation.
When to spend more?
Move up if you want a timer, a shut-off, a switch or Greek thickness from the same box. Manual start-stop control is the first thing people miss once batches become routine.
8. Suteck 8 Jar Maker: Best for Long 48-Hour Ferments
Suteck Yogurt Maker with 8 Jars, Adjustable Time & Temp Control, Black
- Wide time and temperature range handles 36-hour probiotic ferments
- Lid channels condensation back into the reservoir not the electronics
- Sealing lids work well for fridge storage
- Simple panel prompts and easy cleaning
- Runs hotter than the dial reading
- Two-bowl variant has jar indentations that heat unevenly
- Thin manual and a lid that is not locked in place
The Suteck’s selling point is range. Time adjusts from zero to 48 hours and temperature from 68 to 131 degrees, with stated precision within one degree for long slow ferments. That makes it one of the few machines here able to run the 36-hour cycles probiotic-focused users ask about.
The lid design is genuinely thoughtful. Condensation runs back into the water reservoir rather than onto the electronics, and many owners run those long ferments without trouble.
Calibration is the dominant complaint. Owners report a setting of 106 degrees producing 115 or higher, so they calibrate downward with an external thermometer. The two-bowl variant also has indentations for eight small jars that the bowls do not sit flush against, creating uneven heating.
The clear lid is not locked in place, so moving the unit mid-cycle is a risk, and the manual is thin on basic operation.
Reasons to pick it
It fits people running long, low-temperature probiotic cycles, and anyone who wants one machine covering both eight small jars and two larger bowls depending on the variant.
Reasons to look elsewhere
Skip it if you want a single fixed temperature, plan to move the unit mid-cycle, or need accurate dial readings more than a wide range. An external thermometer is close to mandatory here.
9. DiDimo Greek Yogurt Maker: Best for Soy and Natto Ferments
- Strainer included
- which is unusual at this level
- Compact size that still holds a full 1-quart container
- Multifunctional with natto and cheese presets
- Stainless liner is durable and easy to sanitize
- Presets do not disclose actual temperatures and readings fluctuate
- Manual omits the heat and cool milk step
- Some units have failed electronically within a few months
The DiDimo is defined by what arrives in the box. You get a strainer alongside the 1-quart stainless container, so the ferment-to-Greek path is complete without a second purchase, which almost nothing at this level offers.
The natto preset is the sleeper feature. Extending that program to 36 hours also gives experienced users a route to L. reuteri, and it makes this a genuine multi-culture machine. All parts except the heating unit are dishwasher safe.
Reliability is the concern. Reviews mention dead control panels after a few months with no manufacturer response, and the presets never disclose real temperatures, so measured readings fluctuate widely. The manual is written in poor English and skips the heat-and-cool step, which causes first-batch confusion.
The strainer also sits slightly low, so some yogurt stays in contact with the draining whey, and the acrylic lid can arrive cracked.
Who it suits?
It suits soy fermenters, natto makers, and anyone who wants a strainer in the box at a modest outlay. If you already know your temperature targets, the presets are just a shortcut.
Who should avoid it?
Pass if you need a machine you can leave running for days or want dependable factory support. The electronics failure reports decide it for most people.
10. Party Dessert Electric Greek Yogurt Maker: Best for Large Batches
- Largest batch size in this roundup
- Integrated filter makes Greek-style straining simple
- Some users get thick enough yogurt to skip straining
- Fast cleanup and smooth consistent texture
- Only two fixed temperature settings
- Plastic construction with a lid some buyers find loose
- Some arrived used and repackaged without a manual
Capacity is the reason to look here. Two 2-liter inner buckets mean roughly two liters of milk per run, the largest batch in this roundup by a wide margin, and a long-term owner who has made yogurt for a decade rates it as the best machine they have owned.
The integrated filter and receiving container make the Greek step unusually simple, and several users report results thick enough that no straining is needed. Two fermentation modes let you pick a mild or stronger profile.
Temperature control is the compromise. There are only two fixed settings, around 100 and 110 degrees, with no true adjustment, which rules out the long warm cultures programmable models handle. The plastic build and a lid that can feel loose are also flagged.
One reviewer received a used, repackaged machine with no manual, and the instruction sheet is not available in Spanish. Straining is a separate manual step rather than a programmed one.
Where it makes sense?
It fits large families, batch cooking for the week, and anyone who wants Greek thickness from an integrated filter instead of a separate basket. The footprint stays modest for the volume it produces.
Where it does not?
Pass if you chase specific probiotic species, need a wide temperature range, or want glass contact surfaces. Two fixed settings is a narrow tool for experimentation.
11. GDOR Digital Yogurt Maker: Best Full-Range Control With Eight Glass Jars
GDOR Yogurt Maker Machine with Temperature Control, 48H Timer Digital Greek Yogurt Machine with 8×6oz BPA-Free Glass Jars, Stainless Steel
- Full temperature range and 48 hour timer in a compact unit
- Eight glass jars allow multiple flavors in one batch
- Readable LCD makes settings straightforward
- BPA-free components and food-grade glass jars
- Smallest review base of the digital models
- No strainer included
- so Greek thickness needs separate equipment
The GDOR covers the widest temperature band here, from 68 to 131 degrees, with a timer running to 48 hours, and pairs that with eight 6oz glass jars. That combination covers long probiotic ferments and a full week of single-serving breakfast jars in one run.
The clear LCD panel is the part we like most. Settings are obvious at a glance, which matters on a machine with this many combinations, and the stainless body feels substantial for its size.
The obvious limitation is history. This is a newer listing with the smallest review base among the digital models, so long-term reliability is not well established, and we would treat the first few months as an extended test.
There is no strainer in the box either, so plan on a separate straining step for Greek thickness.
Why consider it?
It suits someone who wants programmable range plus glass jars and prefers a readable digital panel to a dial. Eight jars is the widest flavor variety here.
Why wait?
Established models in this class carry thousands of reviews, and that track record is worth something on a heating appliance. Consider this if you want the range and accept the uncertainty.
12. ANZKTOS 6 Jar Maker: Best for Culture Temperature Precision
Yogurt Maker 6 Jars with Temp & Timer Control for Probiotic
- Strongest stated probe accuracy among programmable models
- Suited to long 36-hour sensitive culture cycles
- Six jars yield about a quart per batch
- Compact footprint and straightforward controls
- Smallest capacity of the programmable units at 1 quart
- No strainer included
- Newer listing with a limited review base
The ANZKTOS is the one to look at if your priority is holding a narrow temperature window. Its probe is stated as accurate within 2 degrees across a 68 to 122 degree range, and it is designed around 36-hour sensitive culture cycles rather than a quick six-hour set.
Six 6oz glass jars give about a quart per batch, the smallest output among the programmable models, and the unit is compact enough for a small counter.
One quart per batch is the trade-off. If you need a gallon you run four cycles, and consistency between those cycles becomes the variable that matters. There is also no strainer, so Greek thickness needs a separate basket or sieve.
As a newer listing it carries a limited review base, so treat the accuracy claim as promising rather than proven over years of use.
Reasons to buy
It fits anyone running sensitive cultures over long cycles, and anyone who wants tighter temperature control than a dial-based machine gives at a comparable outlay.
Reasons to choose differently
Pick a larger model if you batch for a family, and pick a strainer if Greek yogurt is the whole goal. Precision on a small batch is a narrow advantage when you are straining anyway.
Strainer vs Incubator: Which One You Actually Need?
Start with where your yogurt comes from. If you buy plain yogurt most weeks, a strainer is the entire decision, because fermentation adds nothing you need. Two quarts of regular yogurt through a fine mesh basket gives roughly a quart of thick Greek, the process is passive, and the tool lasts for years.
If you want control over sugar, additives, cultures and batch size, an incubator earns its counter space. The trade is that you still strain afterward unless the model includes a basket or a dedicated Greek program.
Cost per quart favors the strainer for most households. A strainer reaches Greek thickness in hours of passive draining, while an incubator adds eight to twelve hours of heating before straining even begins, and it still needs a strainer to get there. The incubator only wins on cost per quart if you eat a lot of yogurt, and it wins on quality only if you care about what is in it.
The same batch-size logic applies to other countertop appliances, and we have covered the spectrum from soda makers to waffle makers.
How to Make Thick Greek Yogurt Step by Step?
Whether you use a strainer or a machine, the sequence is the same.
Heat the milk to about 180 degrees F. This denatures the whey proteins that give Greek yogurt its body. Do not boil.
Cool to 110-115 degrees F. Above roughly 120 degrees you kill the cultures you just added. Most thermophilic starters work in the 43-46 degree C window.
Stir in your starter. Two tablespoons of plain whole-milk yogurt per quart of milk works. Use plain, not Greek, and not a flavored variety with pectin or thickeners.
Incubate for 8 to 12 hours. Keep it undisturbed at 110-115 degrees. Longer is tangier, and pooling whey at the edge means it is set.
Strain for 2 to 4 hours. Pour through ultra-fine mesh into a container in the fridge. Save the whey for smoothies or baking.
Two quarts of milk gives about a quart of thick Greek yogurt once the whey is gone, so plan batch size around finished yield rather than starting milk.
How to Choose a Yogurt Maker for Greek Yogurt?
Decide whether you are fermenting or straining. This eliminates half the list. Fermenting means an electric incubator; straining means a mesh basket. Machines that do both save a step and cost more.
Check for a strainer, not a Greek label. A model advertising Greek-style yogurt usually just makes thinner yogurt you strain yourself. Only the Bear, the DiDimo and the Party Dessert unit include an actual basket or filter.
Treat temperature control as the quality driver. Fluctuating incubation temperature is the leading cause of split, grainy or sour results. Fixed-setting machines are fine for a standard eight-hour ferment, but programmability matters for long cultures.
Size the batch to your household. Six-ounce jars suit variety and single servings. A 1-quart container suits one large pot of Greek. Two 2-liter buckets suit batch cooking for a week.
Prefer glass over plastic for fermentation jars, because glass does not carry odors from a strong flavor into a plain batch. Jars in this category are top-rack dishwasher safe in most cases.
Look at cleaning and warranty together. Curved jar walls trap yogurt and are hard to wash, date-setting lids are usually not dishwasher safe, and a three-year warranty or better is a reasonable quality signal.
For plant-based bases, soy works well on most machines, while almond, coconut and oat need slightly warmer starts and thicker stabilizers. The strainer step matters more too, because plant yogurt yields fewer solids. If you also ferment other drinks, our soda maker guide covers the same temperature-control logic.
Starter culture and backslopping. Buy plain whole-milk yogurt once, then use two tablespoons of your own finished batch to start the next. This works indefinitely and removes the recurring starter cost. Add a fresh commercial starter every month or two if flavor or texture drifts.
Do You Even Need a Machine?
Frequently, no. The most useful thread in the yogurt community points out that a sous vide circulator holds temperature more consistently than most dedicated makers, and the same argument applies to an Instant Pot or any appliance with a reliable thermostat.
A sous vide is the strongest alternative if you already own one. Set it to 110-115 degrees, drop in sealed jars, and you get better temperature stability than most incubators here plus the ability to run long ferments without drift. An Instant Pot on its yogurt setting and a slow cooker on warm cover the same ground for small batches. Makers who enjoy tinkering with small appliance projects can also start from the best Raspberry Pi kits and log temperatures themselves.
What none of these replace is convenience and repeatability. A dedicated machine does the same thing every time with one switch, which is why the best yogurt makers for Greek yogurt remain worth buying for anyone making yogurt more than once a week.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can a yogurt maker make Greek yogurt?
Only if it includes a strainer. A standard incubator ferments milk into regular yogurt, and you then strain it through ultra-fine mesh for 2-4 hours to remove whey and reach Greek thickness. Three models here ship with a basket or integrated filter: the Bear with its 100-mesh strainer, the DiDimo with a stainless strainer, and the Party Dessert unit with an integrated filter. With any other incubator you need a separate strainer to get there.
Do you really need a yogurt maker to make yogurt?
No. A sous vide circulator holds temperature more consistently than most dedicated incubators and runs long ferments without drift. An Instant Pot on its yogurt setting, a slow cooker on warm, or even a covered pot in a warm room will ferment milk given time and a thermometer. A dedicated machine earns its place through repeatability, a timer and an automatic shut-off, which matters most if you make yogurt more than once a week.
What is the best Greek yogurt maker for home use?
It depends on whether you ferment or strain. For a strainer-first approach the Hatrigo 1-gallon basket gives the thickest result and the Euro Cuisine GY60 is the compact option for small fridges. For fermenting from scratch the Ultimate Probiotic Maker leads with a 0-48 hour timer and two 1-quart glass containers, and the Bear is the one all-in-one machine that includes a strainer.
How long does it take to make Greek yogurt?
Allow 8-12 hours of incubation at 110-115 degrees, then 2-4 hours of passive draining in the refrigerator. Heating the milk and cooling it back down adds about 30 minutes. Most of the time is unattended, so a full batch from milk to thick Greek yogurt fits comfortably inside a day, and the strained result keeps well for about a week.
Why is my homemade yogurt runny?
Runny yogurt usually means one of three things. The batch was incubated too warm, which kills the culture before it sets. The incubation was too short, so give it the full 8-12 hours undisturbed. Or the yogurt was never strained, since incubation alone produces regular thickness, not Greek. Check the temperature with an external thermometer first, since several machines run 10-15 degrees above the dial reading.
The Verdict for 2026
If you want control over culture, batch size and timing, the Ultimate Probiotic Maker is the strongest all-round machine here, and the Euro Cuisine YM80 is the cheapest reliable way to begin making yogurt from scratch. If you want one box that does both jobs, the Bear includes a strainer and a dedicated Greek program.
If you eat Greek yogurt most days and buy plain tubs instead, start with the Hatrigo strainer. It gets you the thickest result with zero learning curve, and you can add an incubator later if you decide you want to ferment.
Whichever route you take, buy a thermometer. Temperature drift is the biggest reason homemade batches disappoint, and knowing the actual water temperature solves more problems than any feature on any list.